| Original 1937 Foreword | |
| * | 1902 - Benjamin F. Osborn |
| * | 1903 - Benjamin F. Osborn |
| * | 1904 - Arthur Jackson |
| * | 1905 - Charles O. Johnson |
| * | 1906 - John D. Sullivan |
| *§ | 1907 - Edw. M. R. Howe |
| * | 1908 - William C. Moffitt |
| * | 1909 - John B. Hessong |
| * | 1910 - William C. Moffitt |
| * | 1911 - William C. Moffitt |
| * | 1912 - Geo. W. Armentrout |
| *§ | 1913 - Elmore H. Pursel |
| * | 1914 - John W. Ferguson |
| * | 1915 - Webster Wright |
| *§ | 1916 - Samuel R. Rinkard |
| *§ | 1917 - G. Albert Lehman |
| *¶ | 1918 - Edward F. Burrows |
| * | 1919 - James A. Mitchell |
| *§ | 1920 - Alexander Clark |
| * | 1921 - David W. Goldrick |
| *§ | 1922 - Chas. McK Dawson |
| * | 1923 - C. Orville Johnson |
| *§ | 1924 - Oscar P. Roetter |
| * | 1925 - William D. Moffat |
| * | 1926 - Arthur F. Hess |
| * | 1927 - Stanley B. Sheard |
| * | 1928 - Charles W. Clark |
| *§ | 1929 - Forrest M. Logan |
| * | 1930 - O. P. Throckmorton |
| *§ | 1931 - David Clark |
| * | 1932 - Charlie Van Meter |
| * | 1933 - Morris E. Conly |
| * | 1934 - Alexander West, Jr. |
| * | 1935 - Marion A. Klusmann |
| * | 1936 - George E. Tridle |
| *§ | 1937 - Guido E. Schloot |
| * | 1938 - Ralph A. Reidy |
| * | 1939 - Frederick W. Steiger |
| * | 1940 - Donald R. Curtis |
| * | 1941 - Troy W. Scott |
| * | 1942 - Newby D. Apple |
| * | 1943 - George W. Eggleston |
| * | 1944 - Earl W. Mikels |
| * | 1945 - Virgil Breedlove |
| * | 1946 - Eddie C. Barker |
| * | 1947 - Ernest L. Huber |
| *§ | 1948 - Dick DeVries |
| ¶ | 1949 - Karl W. Pouge |
| * | 1950 - Elbert C. Williams |
| * | 1951 - Arthur E. Focke |
| *§ | 1952 - Walter C. Scofield |
| * | 1953 - James R. Couts |
| * | 1954 - Jesse R. Hodshire |
| * | 1955 - Charles R. Hay |
| * | 1956 - Kenneth N. List |
| * | 1957 - Joseph E. Birnell |
| * | 1958 - Robert O. Johnson |
| * | 1959 - Warren G. Sparks |
| * | 1960 - Everett W. Buchanan |
| * | 1961 - Thomas H. Chilton |
| * | 1962 - Jean C. Kassebaum |
| * | 1963 - Fred Corya, Jr. |
| * | 1964 - V. VanCauwenbergh |
| * | 1965 - Glen D. Hart |
| * | 1966 - William F. Waymire |
| *§ | 1967 - John A. Cross |
| * | 1968 - Robert Paul May |
| * | 1969 - Edward H. O'Nan |
| * | 1970 - Charles D. Rodgers |
| * | 1971 - James R. Sodt |
| 1972 - Edgar W. Hessong | |
| 1973 - Wayne A. Sheets | |
| * | 1974 - Robert W. Thurston |
| *§ | 1975 - Francis W. Manifold |
| * | 1976 - Roy A. Bates |
| * | 1977 - William G. Hager |
| * | 1978 - David L. Lanouette |
| * | 1979 - Charles W. Hutchings |
| 1980 - Michael E. Myers | |
| * | 1981 - Maurice B. Sexson |
| 1982 - Robert E. Strader | |
| * | 1983 - G. Ray Cochran |
| ¶ | 1984 - William H. Woodruff III |
| 1985 - Keith A. Hessong | |
| 1986 - Charles D. Lakin | |
| 1987 - Charles W. Beeler | |
| * | 1988 - Robert W. Keller |
| 1989 - Daniel S. Hill | |
| 1990 - Kris Williams | |
| 1991 - Gary A. Cravens | |
| 1992 - Roger S. VanGorden | |
| * | 1993 - William F. Waymire |
| *¶ | 1994 - Robert C. Hilgediek |
| 1995 - Dennis A. Coltart | |
| 1996 - Donald C. Seeley | |
| *¶ | 1997 - Robert C. Hilgediek |
| 1998 - Richard W. Reed | |
| 1999 - John K. Oakley | |
| 2000 - Roger S. VanGorden | |
| 2001 - Christopher L. Hodapp | |
| 2002 - Nathan C. Brindle | |
| 2003 - Jerry T. Cowley | |
| 2004 - Paul Lee Hargitt III | |
| 2005 - Todd M. Ebbert | |
| 2006 - Darren J. Klem | |
| 2007 - Mark A. Haworth |
BY AFFILIATION
| *§ | 1940 - Harley M. Reel |
| 1942 - Brayton P. Deal, Sr. | |
| *§ | 1951 - Melvin F. Hay |
| 1978 - Jerry T. Cowley (see note 1) | |
| * | 1986 - William T. Marshall |
| ¶ | 1991 - Irwin H. "Irv" Sacks |
| ¶ | 1997 - Lawrence M. Smith |
| 1993 - Lawrence S. Lehner | |
| 2007 - Timothy R. Brinkmeyer |
| * | C. L. Kirk, 1 Jan 1902 |
| * | S. B. Plasket, 4 Dec 1903 |
| * | John B. Hessong, 19 Aug 1904 |
| * | Wm. Dawson, 8 Dec 1905 |
| * | C. J. Shepherd, 3 Dec 1909 |
| * | Benjamin W. Heaton, 1 Dec 1911 - 2 Jan 1912 (resigned) |
| * | Wm. Dawson, 2 Jan 1912 |
| * | Robt. A. Glaubke, 5 Dec 1912 |
| * | Benjamin W. Heaton, 3 Dec 1915 |
| * | Thomas W. McMeans, 1 Dec 1916 |
| * | Edw. M. R. Howe, P.M., 6 Dec 1918 |
| * | Scott L. Denny, 19 Dec 1922 |
| * | David W. Goldrick, P.M., 5 Dec 1924 |
| * | Floyd D. Wright, 3 Dec 1926 - 29 June 1944 (deceased) |
| * | Stanley B. Sheard, P.M., 4 Aug 1944 |
| * | Burton Breedlove, 6 Dec 1946 |
| * | Stanley B. Sheard, P.M., 5 Dec 1947 |
| * | Kenneth N. List, P.M., 3 Dec 1965 - 2 May 1975 (resigned) |
| * | Robert W. Thurston, P.M., 2 May 1975 |
| * | William G. Hager, P.M., 2 Dec 1977 - 9 Feb 1979 (deceased) |
| * | David L. Lanouette, P.M., 2 Mar 1979 |
| * | William F. Waymire, P.M., 7 Dec 1979 - 7 Mar 1980 (resigned?) |
| Edgar W. Hessong, P.M., 7 Mar 1980 | |
| * | Edward H. O'Nan, P.M., 2 Dec 1988 - 31 Oct 1991 |
| Edgar W. Hessong, P.M., 6 Dec 1991 | |
| * | G. Ray Cochran, P.M., 3 Dec 1993 |
| Jerry T. Cowley, P.M., 5 Dec 1997 | |
| Donald C. Seeley, P.M., 4 Dec 1998 | |
| Christopher L. Hodapp, P.M., 13 Dec 2001 | |
| Nathan C. Brindle, P.M., 12 Dec 2002 | |
| Darren J. Klem, P.M., 29 Dec 2007 (current) |
| Thomas K. Bathauer, P.M. | |
| * | David W. Bosworth, P.M. |
| Timothy R. Brinkmeyer, P.M. | |
| Jerry T. Cowley, P.M. (see note 1) | |
| William J. Curtis, P.M. | |
| James R. Dillman, P.M. | |
| Douglas O. Fegenbush, P.G.M. | |
| Phillip A. Garver | |
| John E. Grein, P.G.M. | |
| Robert W. Holler, P.M. | |
| * | Ralph W. Hook, P.M. |
| James A. Hanson, P.M. | |
| Wilson H. Lorick, P.M. | |
| * | Samuel W. Pierson, P.M. |
| Michael R. Ricketts, P.M. | |
| Willard V. Saylor (see note 2) | |
| Cecil Taylor, P.M. | |
| * | John W. Thornburgh, P.G.M. |
| Gene E. Wessel, P.M. | |
| Cleon H. Wright, P.M. |
* Deceased § 50-year Members ¶ Demitted
Note 1: Worshipful Brother Cowley re-affiliated with Broad Ripple Lodge in 1993 after having served as Master of Centre Lodge No. 23 in 1978. He served as Master of Broad Ripple Lodge in 2003.
Note 2: Tendered honorary membership in 2001 while a member of Centre Lodge No. 23, Brother Saylor affiliated with Broad Ripple Lodge by transfer in 2003.
